Pages

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Some Conservative Parents Oppose Letting Prez Obama Speak to Kids -- Updated

President Barack Obama’s plan to give a nationally telecast speech to school children about the importance of education is encountering opposition from Conservative groups across reports the New York Times and the Associated Press.



President Obama is appearing live at a high school in Virginia next Tuesday (Sept. 8) and his speech will be simulcast on the White House’s web site. The White House would like schools across the country to tune in.

Right-wing talk radio is in an uproar warning parents that President Obama wants to indoctrinate their children evoking comments like this:
The thing that concerned me most about it was it seemed like a direct channel from the President of the United States into the classroom, to my child.” said Brett Curtiss, an engineer from Pearland, TX, who said he would keep his three children home.
Thankfully the Times found more sensible adults:
“It’s difficult for me to understand how listening to the president, the commander in chief, the chief citizen of this country is damaging to the youth of today,” said Phyllis Griffin Epps, an analyst for [Houston] who has two children in public school.”

Just like Ms. Epps I think the whole notion of keeping kids from listening to the President of the United States is quite frankly silly. Obviously there are many people who disagree with President Obama’s policies, but it’s still valuable for children of all ages hear what he has to say.

Instead of shutting their eyes and ears parent and teachers can turn the President’s speech into a teachable moment and have students discuss what they’ve just heard or give a lesson about civics or history.

In fact the federal Department of Education has prepared a list of sample activities both for younger students (preK to Grade 6) and older students (Grade 7 to Grade 12). One sample question asks elementary school students, "Why do you think he wants to speak to you?" Middle school and High School students are asked, "We heard President Obama mention the importance of personal responsibility. In your life, who exemplifies this kind of responsibility? How? Give examples."

I’ve e-mailed interim superintendant Willliam Papallo to see if Norwalk students will be hearing President Obama’s address and if there is any policy that will allow students to opt-out.

I’d also be interested in hearing from teachers, parents an students as to what you think about the President being able to address the student of America.

UPDATE:

I met with Assistant Superintendent Tony Daddona this morning. Mr. Daddona thought that the speech would be "historic," however the decision to watch the program will be up to principals and teachers at each school.

He also said that the district had received several emails yesterday from parents asking for their kids to "opt out" of watching President Obama's address and in response has prepared this statement:
In answer to your request about the President's speech, I have been asked to inform you that the schools will do as they have always done with such issues. The program must be integrated and aligned with our curriculum in order to be shown in class. In addition, there will be no political position taken by any staff members. Stuents will have the opportunity to opt out of viewing the program should it be shown in their class, in which case they will be provided with an alternative educational activity. Finally, parents have the opportunity to inform the school that they do one want their student to participate in the viewing.

9 comments:

  1. As a parent I absolutely applaud President Obama for this. No matter your politics, he is the President of the United States and these children are citizens who hold the future of this country in their hands. Those on the right are wrong. Were he merely a candidate for office, or a religious leader, etc... that would be inappropriate. The message is wonderful, it is needed and the Obama Administration should be lauded.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am not politically active (I do vote, of course), and I have no strong allegiance to a political party, but I am deeply concerned by the conservative talk hosts who are so polarizing our nation. Ironically, they refer to themselves as the "true patriots," but true patriots respect the American values of freedom of speech and freedom of expression, as well as the belief that this is a living country; as such, there has to be change to meet the changing needs of the people of this country.

    Anyone who calls himself a patriot is blowing smoke. It means far more for someone else to call a person a patriot.

    ReplyDelete
  3. These republicans are nuts. I suppose it's alright when Bush I and Reagan do it but not Obama. Oh and we all know where GWB was when the September 11 attacks started.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with the posters above. I applaud President Obama for speaking directly to the children of this nation and engaging them in discussions on personal responsibility and the importance of staying in school - especially when there are so many young people in our country (and in our city) who elect to drop out.

    I find it disturbing that people would choose to listen to talk show hosts, like Rush Limbaugh, a drug addict and hypocrite, above that of President Obama. Boggles the mind.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It makes you realize how difficult it is for the government to get anything done with all of these roadblocks to communication and misrepresentation of information. So much vile behavior from the right! When people start trying to censor the president, we've got real problems.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think having our students listen to the President of the United States is such a terrific, teachable moment also. I know as parents we have our children watch the televised speeches the President gives. Hopefully our Norwalk Schools will allow the kids this terrific opportunity!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I arrived home to listen to a recorded message from my son’s superintendent of schools explaining why listening to President Obama’s speech is going to be an important, teachable moment in my child’s life. In Norwalk, the best we got was an e-mail saying that it’s up to each individual teacher. Norwalk parents, you deserve so much better than this from your central office staff. Please take the BOE elections very seriously.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The audacity of President Obama to actually go on the air and tell our children to*gasp* stay in school, work hard and achieve their dreams like he did. This is basically what they racist, intellectually limited far far right is saying. My children are excited for this moment, and I wish I could join them in class that day -- President Obama is an absolute inspiration to all -- no matter your politics or your personal views, I am truly proud to be an American who helped put such an incredible man in office. I absolutely applaud him.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am not a fan of Obama and when I heard that he was going to give a speech to our children I immediately signed the paper for my son not to participate. Yesterday, I took the time to read his speech and printed the speech read it at home during dinner to the kids and my husband (he is not a fan, either). We do respect the position just do not share his political views. Anyway, If the BOE would have been clear on what was going to be discussed, which was by the way, very encouraging and it applied to the YOUNG people of America 5-23 years old. Then I would have approved it and said yes. Either way, next time please let us know what the speech is about. Thanks.

    PS. Great website very informative!

    ReplyDelete

ShareThis